Separate names with a comma.
Discussion in 'Music' started by WARP, Jan 10, 2017.
Bill Withers is better than Marvin Gaye & Al Green combined.....
WARP talks a lot of sense.
British Hip Hop/Rap [Hijack, Demon Boyz, Caveman, Cash Crew, Overlord X, MC Duke, Silver Bullit etc]
Was better than anything coming from America around at that time
The Brits could scratch better too
Nobody but nobody could hold a light to Marvin Live . . . sorry instant fail! As much as I like Bill both the afore mentioned had better voices .Marvin by a country mile .The only one who came close was when I saw Smokey a few decades back .As an overall artist maybe Bill but as a stand alone singer not a chance .
This + a darkened room two glasses and a bottle of Thunderbird wine .As a young man was 100% success rate . I owe this guy loads .
I love Marvin but it's my opinion
Most people would take Marvin over Bill but in my world it don't & by a long way
I know, it's difficult for me as I saw Marvin at Birmingham Odeon years ago and I knew I was in the presence of greatness .
I don't doubt it for a second.
For me to say I like Bill over Marvin/Al combined is a ****ing outlandish statement but believe it. In my world
That's the point of this thread right ?
I have a friend that thinks the same about Otis . . . you are both wrong!
In a world of not having an opinion isn't it nice to have an opinion
Otis was great
Prefer Bill though!!
Steveland Hardaway Judkins has more talent in his left bollock than anybody mentioned here so far!
No doubting Stevie is talented but he just doesn't blow me frock up.
I judge on what an artist stirs in me, that's why I would pick Otis from the above mentioned.
I was being bolshy.....to be honest,they are all legends in their own right.
You bolshy , never .I'm not having it I tell you.
As I said this guy deserves a mention . Saw him as one of the first acts to play The Symphony Hall in Brum . Magic .Having said that saw a live show last year and his voice has succumbed to old age I'm afraid
I'm a massive fan of Marvin & Al so I cant agree with this. I think Bill Withers back catalogue is on par with Al Greens but 'take me to the river' & 'Lets stay together' are 2 of the greatest soul songs of all time, imo!
Curtis Mayfield was better than all 3 of them combined
Wu Tang Clan (group albums and solo efforts) have produced more classic albums than any other group or artist
The Golden age of Hip Hop was the 90's, and not late 70's through to 1990
Animals is pink floyds greatest album!
lol and so it coninues .
#3 This is just trolling now . LMFAO
This guy before he went shit!