What about fake roleclaims given to mafia? I presume you are saying there's no way malfoy is a fake role claim gifted to someone? (if not why not)
Malfoy is an antagonist in the books, I cannot see any scum motivation in softclaiming to be Draco on Day1
so you are quite happy based on character its not a fake role claim and are putting sandsy in the town grouping. Any thoughts on the vision bit, is there a character that would send that or a role in mafia that would send it?
This is a fair point and worth remembering that fake claims have been given out. That said, I agree with Guyett. If Sandsy were scum, Malfoy isn't the greatest fake claim. I was curious that Sandsy had crumbed Malfoy yesterday for much that reason. Gives me a town-lean for now although a vote from Josh would help clear up part of Sandsy's role. "Nothing to report" tells you how busy I was. My comment on others being busier was in relation to Zydus suggesting a lot happened last night.
Maybe its just me after last two games where mafia made a big play early but its not just a miller role (aka breadcrumbed malfoy day 1, drop in miller day 2). its also vote thief and that could be either town or mafia right? maybe its paranoia at play but I'd like to understand as this doesn't seem "normal" game to me if someone has two distinct roles there. It does feel like its complicated.
So don't ask question then? is that the message? First, do you think this is a "normal" game or something more complicated based on whats dropped so far (even as claims) second, i for one don't want anyone getting an easy ride like the last two games just cos they come out of the blocks strong. We've got a role claim, a character claim, a secondary compulsion to steal votes AND a vision that was unexpected. I'd say that is worth a few questions Third I've seen it said on last games about policy lynches base don roles like miller but not this time so i've said it.
I'm pretty content with Lugna at the moment. I don't think town-Lugna would be playing much differently. He's usually one to probe and question pretty much anything. Could potentially be scum-fishing but don't feel anything off with Lugna yet. I wouldn't assume anything normal about a wizard / witch / magic themed game tbh. Zydus has suggested there may be bastard elements.
Looking at Malfoy, seems like whilst he's an arsehole he isn't necessarily evil per se. A few moments he does help Harry and the others.So the miller type role alongside that makes me believe the claim even more. Anyway vote garrincha A hunch. Just based on very unusually quiet play so far.
Doesn't look great when a player is called out for being inactive and then responds immediately. Perhaps just unfortunate timing that Garrincha is online at the time of Sheen's post but it tickled me nonetheless that Garrincha was here straight away to respond to it Anything to add @Frosty ? I can see you lurking so your invisibility cloak isn't working You've been pretty quiet so far too.
To me he seems to be his usual self. I get a gut feeling is sometimes unexplainable but is there anything you have noticed which is different about his play so far?
