I've always maintained every single move in this game has pros and cons for being made by both Town and Scum. Working out the motivations behind those moves is in essence the name of the game.
@The Doc This happened earlier in the game, well before Scunny was lynched. This has me doubting the idea the Sgt is in fact mafia. I can't see him doing this back then, then continuing the argument 4/5 days later if they were both mafia. Sgt was also happy to vote for Scunny here. This was the 5th vote of the 6 needed. With a lynch so close why would he risk losing a team mate? The people that didn't vote to lynch Scunny were.. RM - scum BB - presumed scum by myself Bob - presumed pennywise Doc - apparent townie virgin
Vc 5.1. BB (1) Bob Bob (1) Sgt Not Voting (3): BB, Wafc Dan, Doc 5 players requires 3 to lynch Deadline is 9pm Saturday
Right lads get your shit together. Doc and Sgt town. I know I am... Town Bb or Dan.. Or both My vote us on Bb..
Still very confused by Bob's posts at the start, at the time I assumed he had a weird role where getting lynched was his win condition, but I don't think they really happen outside of bastard games. Now thinking he's scum and he decided that by basically daring us to lynch him we wouldn't and he'd then be safe for most the game. vote bob
There's a post from Bob were he says if we don't lynch RM/Sgt then we should lynch him. That could suggest he's not actually on the side of mafia as he wanted RM gone back then.
Bobs erratic play still doesn't truly sit right with me. Dan I believe is Town. Dunno what to make of BB. All the parents / obscure characters have been scum thus far but I know the formula isn't that simple as I'm a parent and Town. Yourself, not sure. Your claimed role is perfect cover for not being NKed which is great Scum cover. I have no idea how well the role claim fits the character because I know nothing about the IT franchise. Me - Scunny tried to take me down. I was on his wagon and I hammered RM, also scum. Far from conclusive proof but enough to earn me some Town credit imo.
Bobs erratic play still doesn't truly sit right with me. Dan I believe is Town. Dunno what to make of BB. All the parents / obscure characters have been scum thus far but I know the formula isn't that simple as I'm a parent and Town. Yourself, not sure. Your claimed role is perfect cover for not being NKed which is great Scum cover. I have no idea how well the role claim fits the character because I know nothing about the IT franchise. Me - Scunny tried to take me down. I was on his wagon and I hammered RM, also scum. Far from conclusive proof but enough to earn me some Town credit imo.
Vc 5.2 BB (2) Bob, Doc Bob (2) Sgt, Bb Not Voting (1): Wafc Dan 5 players requires 3 to lynch Deadline is 9pm Tonight
