I was the best player of the game, clearly. LOL. Seriously though, Mike and Furno did well, inconspicuously writing simply wtf everywhere to everything. AJ messed up in my eyes after Kopite's kill and so did Kopite as he sent me a PM asking why I killed him. My bad on Craig, but I did spot 2 other Sith. I agree with Mike, the sensor ability should be modified since it's a similar tactic in each game. I also agree with Guyett where there should be a lesser number of people involved. I'd entrust Guyett with hosting a game in any case, since I think he plays at other forums as well.
My favourite bit was when I got PM'd that I must change my vote to JR (when we were voting the bomb). I had not even voted. Thought the magia should have changed NH to no lynch to tie the vote. Unfortunately I was then told I couldnt let anyone know about the f*** up. Well played mafia only started to suspect mike near end and never suspected furno at all.
Think I might sit the next one out, allow my interest to renew itself. Might just be because I got killed early but the previous game was so much better. I agree that we should remove the Sensor. It just means we focus entirely on lists and the mafia can easily split themselves as they did here.
Or, make it be a little more limited. Like you can pick up to 6 people to use it on etc, assuming they all voted the same way. Not half the flipping group.
Just remove it. The game should be about intuition, not working through silly lists. Or at least work through lists we've put together ourselves, not had created for us. Completely ruined it. That was why it was so inactive, no one needed to talk. The majority of the game was just a waiting game until 10pm every night to knock off the next person in group 2.
Ok here's what I'm thinking No sensor, no lie detector. They are both over powered and remove all fun from the game. Lie detector just encourages people to blurt out what role they have and sensor kills all aspects of actual mafia hunting. Also mafia will be using a different chatroom thing. Chatzy doesn't store all of the chat and it can't be locked.. instead we'd use quicktopic. The reason for this is I am removing mafia day chat. Mafia should only talk at night time. Also all roles like cop and doc are done over night. If we're doing a 13 player game the mafia might get one player who is a mafia encryptor. While this player is alive mafia get day talk. Cop only gets players alignment, they aren't told the persons role. I'm also removing the deathproofness of the godfather. Mafia have to chose which of their team preforms the night kill. If that person is jailed (for example) then the mafia kill fails. The only possible roles are: Mafia godfather - investigates as town Mafia roleblocker - blocks a persons ability to use a power Mafia encryptor - enables day chat Mafia goon - like a vanilla townie but mafia aligned Town Cop - investigates a person to fond out if they are mafia or town aligned Town Doc - protects a person from being killed over night Town Jailkeeper - basically a roleblocker and doc rolled into one. the person jailed is safe from any night action but cannot use their power Town Tracker - chose one player to follow and find out if they visited anyone that night, however you aren't told what action they did Town one shot Bulletproof - they survive the first time they are shot (either mafia night kill or town vig shot) Town 1 or 2 shot Day Vig - number of shots depends on game size. they can kill during the day Town Miller - investigates as mafia Vanilla Town - only power is their vote.
Count me in Guyett, May not work in a game that size but I always like the mafia recruiter power, can really be a mind screwer
I could do an absolute bastard game with any number of players and one cult recruiter that recruits one per day until the cult outnumber the town. no night kills but there are lynches. If the original cult member dies all cult dies and town wins.....
As for this game I made the mistake of assuming Sith could only do their stuff at night otherwise I would have had AJ when I went to do my 3rd investigation, so poor playing on my part for that. We'd have had AJ a day or two earlier.
The night that seagull was saved I think we were looking at killing NH. Had we done it we would of removed the sensor role before it was publicized but we chose seagull instead.
So why did Furno kill me? Also Sgt Serious, as much as I would have liked to have taken credit for saying RM was mafia in the chatroom, I wasn't ever in that chatroom as Rob and David never gave me the link for it, so whoever showed up as 'LEF' must have been a fake.
Killing me made no sense from a Sith point of view as it looked as though I was going to be lynched anyway, as I was an easy target.
