Well lads that was fun, there was a lot of stupid moves by people but some quality moves. Aj silencing dawg when someone was in jail was inspired. Cartel were great for the start of the game but got really stupid late on, it got really obvious they were cartel after a while. GG all
If Josh had of outed himself I think we'd have won? Would haven been far more inclined to believe 20L if it was known the Doctor wasnt one of the 3 main suspects...
Indeed. Round 1 originals us. We need a break before we come back to this. Probably a 20 member one like the first one itself.
It took a while for the penny to drop in Cartel HQ as well.... ...but...if you're the Cop and you find out who your Doctor is and you want to confirm him as a Townie but have no one go near him, then bomb is the perfect cover really isnt it. At one point I started to doubt there even was a Doctor - not sure why he saved you over the Mayor last phase, perhaps he thought we'd think the Mayor was safe and avoid him I suppose?
yes it is very easy for them to win imo town won because there was no way for mafia to win and it'd take too long to finish the game properly so I finished it for the mods :P yeah glad it went well it was fun to watch.
yes it was really good play from DAWG imo, He had some great moments and some really retarded moments.
Did either mafia or Cartel even consider trying to lynch me on the first night when I was trying to claim to be the cop?
Nah, we didn't really think you were a threat to us tbh. We knew you weren't the cop and hoped the Townies would waste time trying to lynch you instead of us.
I don't think there's much to be done about it though. It's luck of the draw if we get well-balanced teams and the mafia don't get lucky early then the game has a lot of legs, I think role duplication and other methods of enhancing powers cause more trouble than they're worth. Half the game is spent trying to work out if there's 2 of everything and add to that that the mafia can often recruit somebody, adding to the confusion. I think it's fairly heavily biased against the town.
it was a bit different this game, had it been a one mafia game your play would have been very suspicious but with 2 mafias most people would play a different game.
we originally had 2 cops but we swapped to 2 lie detectors here. We could only have one cop for our jail event. We brought in the shortening night day cycles to keep it fresh, with 2 mafias the numbers would shorten very quickly and with other things like jail it was always going to be a short game... this helped keep it from getting stale imo
Anyway well played DV, NH and Dan. And cheers mods. You were helpful in my times of monginess, drunkeness and when i thought i was a genius but couldnt explain myself. One suggestion though and this is no way a criticism but Mods should answer questions and implement the rules. Amy comments on how they see things are going are a bit distracting. its easy when you know everything but we dont. At the end almost nobody knew Josh was Doctor, and not the bomb, even townies.
Maybe....I mean suggesting I was Mafia or Cartel because neither of them had Night Killed me - made no sense, regardless of the fact I was Cartel, the Mafia had still chosen not to Night Kill me, knowing full well everyone would turn on me (I assume thats why the Mafia didnt hit me?)
