Just going back through, I think this makes TLC likely not group-scum. What is essentially a scum vampire tracker doesn't seem like a likely role for scum to have at all, imo. Also the word "mafia", now put in this context makes her seem town-like: if you were mafia, and with this role, you wouldn't describe it in this way. You'd either use the words "not town" or "third-party"
I have believed Andys role claim albeit i don't believe people with power roles like a doctor miss a night action. Especially when Zydus said PM me at any time if you are going to be busy. Josh said he jailkept me last night.....but I can't recall who he has used his ability on previously? Would be good to have this information.
You again on N2, because nothing dissuaded me from my thinking you were group scum in that time. Not really answered Joga's question here
Note: scum chose to kill the 'even-night cop' over the 'even-night tracker', N4. Both cop/tracker were likely were going to target Sme/Andy Flavour spec: i do think mafia have a strongman (Jason Voorhees, basically one the strongest nutters ever) Does a strongman bypass protections/jailkeepers?
There was a lot of other stuff going on during D2 so it was only during the night phase I properly looked back and started to form reads not based off of that day's events. Day 3 we had the whole RD thing but I still expressed my concern on you that day phase.
If you in theory successfully jailkept Sme on N2 too, he did not kill Sheen then (or kill the person Sheen protected via his role). Every kill by groupscum has been successful so far
Yep. Probably fell for a bit of WIFOM last night - thought Sme would do the kill as scum wouldn't expect me to block him again. Obviously not though so Sme is either not doing the kills (I personally think this is most likely) or a vampire
Still got concerns with Andy’s roleclaim. Andy tries to palm it off as an odd night version of Mr Sheens power: HOWEVER, their powers are nothing alike. Mr Sheen was an even night bodyguard. Andy is claiming an odd night doctor. I didn’t like his choice of protection either (Guyett), despite having 3 quasi-confirmed town players alive.
Quick note: There still must be another ghost out there. Burg had an odd night role to trap ghosts. RD is the only flipped ghost so far.
Set-up summary (please advise if I have anything wrong/missing): We likely started with 9 town aligned players and 4 non-town-aligned players, as follows: (9x TOWN: 6 DEAD, 3 ALIVE) Scunnymadandy [1-shot day vig] Killed N1 Frosty [ODD night watcher] Lynched D2 Mr. Sheen [EVEN night bodyguard] Killed N2 RedDevil19 [Universal backup / ghost] Lynched D3 Burg [ODD night jailkeeper of ghosts] Killed N3 Sgt. Serious [EVEN night cop] Sent result to Jason N2. Killed N4 (2x SCUM) Jason Voorhees? Ghost? (1x CULT) Guyett [CULT] Lynched D4 Recruited RD (N1? ‘familiar’), Sgt Serious, +1(?) (1x SURVIVOR) Jason [SURVIVOR] Died N2 Picked Andy D1, Mr Sheen D2. Still alive on D5… (3 TOWN : 2 SCUM or 2 TOWN : 1 CULT : 2 SCUM) Joga bonito [ODD night cop, sent result to Sheen N1, Andy N3] JoshBCFC [EVEN night jailkeeper of ‘not town’]. Jailkept Sme N2 and N4. TLC [EVEN night tracker of movement] caught RD N2 (scum get notified). Tracked Sgt Serious N4. Hashtag55 [ODD night doctor]. Protected Guyett N3. Sme [PGO of scum]
By pro-active scum hunting since D1, here are my rankings: 1 Josh 2 TLC 3 Sme 4 Andy By how much I like their character claims: 1 TLC 2 Josh 3 Andy 4 Sme Scum most likely in [Sme, Andy]
Morning all - any more insight into mafia candidates ? I'm still leaning Hashtag as my preferred vote today
I'm also still preferring lynching Hashtag currently. But we can't really progress today unless he comes online and gives us his thoughts @Hashtag55
