A flip from a lynch is not the same thing as a scum team choosing to kill someone. It’s completely different information. A night kill is a town player being chosen to be killed by the scum team. A lynch is a collective. But voting would have helped. However I believe from D3 on half the player base stopped voting. I found out Andy and Will from voting patterns. But by D7 I gave up because no one was voting. Unless I wanted to assume everyone voting was scum, but how was anyone suppose to guess that. Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Its hard to accomplish something like that when you say it and no one listens. It definitely made me think I was missing something. Even if I had pushed you, there was never more town activity than scum. Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
This did make it quite easy. Only you, CV and Trojii contributed much as town making it 4 v 3 or 3 v 3 for over half the game
Think there should have required a majority to lynch tbh, made the game too easy for scum being able to band wagon in the last 5 minutes.
Town made it easy for scum, not the set-up. Everytime there was a suspicious last minute counter wagon or rushed lynch to send scum to heaven, scum were involved - but town (who always outnumbered scum) didn’t use their votes this game (the only power they had).
Plus, town on the last day should have realised there were 3 scum left. Thus, should have agreed to only vote their strongest town read collectively, and not spread all their votes with a single vote (some didn’t even post/vote at LYLO) :/
Pretty much what Joga said. We only voted as we did because we realised that there was so little activity on the town side of the game that we could force things through. Had there been more activity the game would've played out completely differently as we would've played it completely differently. By the end i think it was 9 town to 3 scum, before Steve's vote to heaven. There is no way town should've allowed us to force through anything with numbers like that.
Find me 6 new mafia players who want to hunt ‘nonces’ on a football forum...? Or we stop blaming the mod and look at the collective input of ‘town’ that game.
There was no collective. You keep talking like town had this majority when in reality we never did! You said it yourself just now... 6 replacements were needed? I didn’t even know the number. Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Town had the majority everyday but did not use their vote or scum hunting ability to their advantage. The game had a very basic premise kabs. Town were defeated by scum and themselves. Take the defeat. It was not my fault town lost.
We had a majority in physical numbers, but the people NOT posting were all town. Accept responsibility that you should have done something about that. Replacing those players maybe doesn't change the outcome, but town didn't have a vote. Because the people who could vote as town weren't ****ing playing.
Not jogas fault with people not posting but a majority being required would’ve meant town didn’t sleep walk into nonce hell.
So if you’d done your job and convinced the active players to all vote together you’d have overpowered us.
@kaboose It’s not my job to keep town motivated and persuade them to lynch nonces, neither manage their personal life. No one deserved to be mod-killed. I kept tagging/PM’ing players. I did not think a mass-replace out was realistic either. Scum beat you, and town underperformed. Move on. Look at the last game we played. Town were motivated and we successfully lynched scum everyday. These were the very same players.
